Jon Westfall
Menu

The Students Who Found Their Way

After years of teaching, I've learned that students' futures rarely follow a single path. A reflection on second chances, unexpected success, and why early struggles don't define a life.

I’ve been teaching long enough now that one of the unexpected pleasures of my career is seeing where former students end up. And one of the things I’ve learned from watching them is that I’m not nearly as good at predicting their futures as I might have once thought.

I’ve known students who struggled tremendously during their undergraduate years. Some battled drug or alcohol problems that threatened to derail their education and their lives. At the time, it was difficult to imagine them in positions requiring enormous responsibility, judgment, and leadership. Yet years later, I’ve watched some of those same students overcome their struggles and take on roles that their younger selves might never have imagined possible.

I’ve known students who barely spoke in class, who seemed almost painfully shy, who now lead organizations, command rooms, and inspire others with their energy and enthusiasm. Somewhere along the way, they found a voice that I never had the opportunity to hear.

And I’ve known plenty of students who were absolutely certain about what they wanted to do with their lives, only to end up doing something completely different. Sometimes the change was deliberate. Sometimes life simply presented another opportunity. And from what I can tell, many of them are quite happy with where they landed.

These stories have changed the way I think about success.

When we’re young, we’re often presented with a remarkably narrow vision of how life is supposed to work. Get good grades. Choose the right major. Find the right internships. Make the right connections. Get the right job. Follow the prescribed sequence, and everything will work out.

Parents, teachers, and advisors reinforce this message, usually with the best of intentions. After all, these things do matter. Good grades, relevant experience, and careful planning are associated with better opportunities.

But here’s something we don’t emphasize nearly enough: The things that correlate with success don’t necessarily guarantee it.

You can do everything right and still encounter extraordinary hardship. You can make terrible decisions when you’re young and still build a wonderful life. You can spend years pursuing one destination, discover that it isn’t where you want to be, and find happiness somewhere you never thought to look.

As we get older, we begin to recognize just how much of our lives involve some combination of preparation, circumstance, luck, and timing. We also recognize that there probably wasn’t just one good outcome waiting for us. There were dozens of possible lives we might have lived, many of which could have been equally fulfilling.

I think about this particularly when I meet young people who are convinced that they’ve already ruined their chances. At eighteen or twenty, a failed class, a lost relationship, a rejected application, or a poor decision can feel like a permanent verdict on the rest of your life.

But it isn’t.

And there’s a more painful reason I’ve come to believe this so strongly.

Over the years, I’ve lost a few former students to suicide. They never had the opportunity to grow into the people they might have become. I can’t know everything they were experiencing or what led them to those moments. But I think about them, and about all the possibilities that remained ahead of them, even if those possibilities were difficult to see.

I wish they could have seen what I’ve seen.

I wish they could have seen the student who struggled with addiction become someone others depend upon. Or the quiet student become a leader. Or the young person whose carefully constructed career plans fell apart, only to discover a completely different and satisfying life.

Not because those stories guarantee that everything will turn out well. They don’t. But because they demonstrate something that is terribly difficult to appreciate when you’re young: Your present circumstances are not a reliable prediction of your entire future.

The older I get, the less concerned I become about whether someone is following the correct path. I’ve seen too many paths lead to good places, and too many seemingly perfect plans encounter unexpected obstacles.

If I could tell my younger students one thing, it would be this: Take your opportunities seriously, but don’t mistake any single opportunity for your only chance. Work hard, make plans, and try to make good decisions. But recognize that there is no single sequence of choices that guarantees a happy life.

And when something goes wrong, as it inevitably will, remember that you haven’t necessarily reached the end of anything.

You may simply be somewhere in the middle of a story whose ending you cannot yet imagine.

Leave a Reply